criticalhitgames.myfreeforum.org :: Samurai Championship Global Storyline Event Sun Nov. 9th

Like Eric said people have been skirting the rules all race. Also the points have to be rewarded regardless of whether someone meets the criteria or not, because they are points alloted for our event. Its silly to let them go to waste when people want them.
_________________

I dunno... win the point by the rules maybe? Call me crazy, stupid, honorable or otherwise, but I just don't see doing something because everyone else does it as being acceptable. However much I'd like to help Lion win the military point, I wouldn't take it any other way besides winning it; if I didn't it would just be a hollow victory that I know I didn't earn. But, hey, that's me... I guess if everyone else is fine with it and I'm the only dissenter then who am I to stop everyone else?
_________________

Well I did state in my break down earlier that the winners of the 2 tourny events would get the respective points. Just that if the same person won both events he would have to give either the military or economy point to another clan, his choice. Then the 3 non-tourny related points could split among the clans that didn't win a tournament. In whatever way everyone thinks is most acceptable. whether it be a small debate & vote or each remaining clan chooses a champion for a multiplayer game. Some way points can be divided fairly with out having to go through with the silly things that most of the 7-10 people there wont even be bothering with.
_________________

I see where you're coming from, and I respect the position. However, I just don't agree... that's all. No biggie. However, why exactly should the military and economic point have to go to different people? If the same person wins the constructed and the draft then they earned the respective points for their clan. Sorry to say it, but if I were to win both, which I highly doubt in either category (we all can hope though I suppose) I wouldn't be giving up either one of them as they would both be going to my clan. Deals, agreements and everything else people have done aside, the bottom line stance AEG has taken all along has been that the person who wins the points decides where they go. In some cases you choose before hand, like with military, by choosing the SH you're playing out of. In others, like draft, it's up to the winner.

And as an aside... I'd rather see the economic point go to Dragon than Mantis any day. Just a personal preference.
_________________

I just thought it would be a fair way to do things so no one feels like they got jipped because they didn't want to dress up or got a bad draw in the draft. I mean we can do it the way the rules say, but I just didn't want people to be pissed off or upset if for some reason only 1 or 2 clans get every single point.

Realistically I don't care how it gets done. If a person can get more then one point I will do my best to get as many as I can. If we go the other way then it just makes things easier as I don't have to worry about covering every angle since I can get only one point.
_________________

I will concede to any player during the main tournament who is willing to concede to me during the draft.
_________________
Tsuruchi Pyo (Eric Morgan)
(\ ºvº\ (\

With just a week to go, I figured I'd gauge interest again. I'd be willing to trade cards or whatever for anything that gets me closer to the Econ point. I still have foil SE commons, a few foil SE uncommons, and plenty of other stuff.
_________________
Tsuruchi Pyo (Eric Morgan)
(\ ºvº\ (\

What time is this going to start on Sunday?
_________________

1pm tip-off time!

I'll be handing out the the winners of each "race". The main tournament and the draft may be won by the same person. The other catagories cannot be won by the same person.

Does this go by Clan or Person? Basically can different people win different things for the same clan? Or can the same person win different things for different clans?

And just so I have this straight.

If you/your clan win Military:

You/Your clan can win:
Econ

You/Your clan can't win:
Politics
Knowledge
Spirit

If you/your clan win Econ:

You/Your clan can win:
Military

You/Your clan can't win:
Politics
Knowledge
Spirit

If you/your clan win Politics:

You/Your clan can't win anything else.

If you/your clan win Knowledge:

You/Your clan can't win anything else.

If you/your clan win Spirit:

You/Your clan can't win anything else.
_________________

Author	Message
Mophat Gamer Joined: 31 Dec 2007 Posts: 116 Status: Offline Location: Waterloo, IA	Post subject:
	Like Eric said people have been skirting the rules all race. Also the points have to be rewarded regardless of whether someone meets the criteria or not, because they are points alloted for our event. Its silly to let them go to waste when people want them. _________________

Author	Message
TheEyes100 Newb Joined: 19 Jan 2008 Posts: 72 Status: Offline	Post subject:
	I dunno... win the point by the rules maybe? Call me crazy, stupid, honorable or otherwise, but I just don't see doing something because everyone else does it as being acceptable. However much I'd like to help Lion win the military point, I wouldn't take it any other way besides winning it; if I didn't it would just be a hollow victory that I know I didn't earn. But, hey, that's me... I guess if everyone else is fine with it and I'm the only dissenter then who am I to stop everyone else? _________________

Author	Message
Mophat Gamer Joined: 31 Dec 2007 Posts: 116 Status: Offline Location: Waterloo, IA	Post subject:
	Well I did state in my break down earlier that the winners of the 2 tourny events would get the respective points. Just that if the same person won both events he would have to give either the military or economy point to another clan, his choice. Then the 3 non-tourny related points could split among the clans that didn't win a tournament. In whatever way everyone thinks is most acceptable. whether it be a small debate & vote or each remaining clan chooses a champion for a multiplayer game. Some way points can be divided fairly with out having to go through with the silly things that most of the 7-10 people there wont even be bothering with. _________________

Author	Message
TheEyes100 Newb Joined: 19 Jan 2008 Posts: 72 Status: Offline	Post subject:
	I see where you're coming from, and I respect the position. However, I just don't agree... that's all. No biggie. However, why exactly should the military and economic point have to go to different people? If the same person wins the constructed and the draft then they earned the respective points for their clan. Sorry to say it, but if I were to win both, which I highly doubt in either category (we all can hope though I suppose) I wouldn't be giving up either one of them as they would both be going to my clan. Deals, agreements and everything else people have done aside, the bottom line stance AEG has taken all along has been that the person who wins the points decides where they go. In some cases you choose before hand, like with military, by choosing the SH you're playing out of. In others, like draft, it's up to the winner. And as an aside... I'd rather see the economic point go to Dragon than Mantis any day. Just a personal preference. _________________

Author	Message
Mophat Gamer Joined: 31 Dec 2007 Posts: 116 Status: Offline Location: Waterloo, IA	Post subject:
	I just thought it would be a fair way to do things so no one feels like they got jipped because they didn't want to dress up or got a bad draw in the draft. I mean we can do it the way the rules say, but I just didn't want people to be pissed off or upset if for some reason only 1 or 2 clans get every single point. Realistically I don't care how it gets done. If a person can get more then one point I will do my best to get as many as I can. If we go the other way then it just makes things easier as I don't have to worry about covering every angle since I can get only one point. _________________

Author	Message
PlaguedOne Newb Joined: 18 Jan 2008 Posts: 62 Status: Offline Location: Cedar Falls	Post subject:
	I will concede to any player during the main tournament who is willing to concede to me during the draft. _________________ Tsuruchi Pyo (Eric Morgan) (\ ºvº\ (\

Author	Message
admin Site Admin Joined: 23 Sep 2007 Posts: 954 Status: Offline Location: Coralville, Iowa	Post subject:
	1pm tip-off time! I'll be handing out the the winners of each "race". The main tournament and the draft may be won by the same person. The other catagories cannot be won by the same person.